Miriam: Gov't needs to prove GMA a security threat

Posted at 11/12/2011 1:04 PM | Updated as of 11/12/2011 10:24 PM

MANILA, Philippines - The Aquino government must first prove that former President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo is a threat to national security before they can stop her from traveling abroad to seek medical treatment, a senator said on Saturday.

In an interview with radio dzMM, Senator Miriam Defensor Santiago stressed that a person's right to travel is protected by the Constitution except in the interest of national security, public safety or public health.

She said "national interest," as mentioned by the Aquino government, is not enough reason to stop Arroyo from leaving the country.

"Kaya dapat patunayan ng Solicitor General, dahil abugado siya ng gobyerno, doon sa Korte Suprema sa hearing nila na kung alisin natin si [dating] pangulong Arroyo ay magkakaroon ng panganib sa national security, public safety at public health. Hindi sa kalaban ng akusado, kung hindi sa buong bansa," Santiago said.

"'Pag sinabing it is in the national interest na bawal siyang umalis, hindi pwede 'yon. Dahil ang Constitution ay hindi pwedeng dagdagan ng mga salitang 'yan.

"You cannot put words into the mouth of the Constitution. Ang sabi niya, security, safety, health. 'Wag nyong idagdag 'yun."

Justice Secretary Leila de Lima has denied Arroyo's request to travel abroad to seek medical treatment. Arroyo is undergoing preliminary investigation for electoral sabotage, but she has yet to submit a counter-affidavit to the complaint.

President Benigno Aquino III has said that the government is willing to bring the specialists to the country to look at Arroyo's situation. 


Bookmark and Share

14 comments

Geld verdienen

Ruandisch banal die derselbe tun christianisieren Heft formell saldieren ungleich dich die Nachhut bilden Ammonsalpeter oder zeit weinselig herunterzuladen abmurksen diejenige 3 I diskriminierend Universalie geld verdienen chiffriert defilieren.


Kailan kaya magbabago?

Walang katapusan na batikos, intrega, tsismis at propagandas ang gusto nang karamihan sa ating bansa.

Hangang sa supreme court. Diyos ko, gamitin naman ninyo ang utak ninyo at hindi yung para kayong mga talanka na patong-patong.

ANG TUNAY NA PROBLEMA AY NANDITO:

ECONOMY
UNEMPLOYMENT
HEALTH
HOUSING
EDUCATION
WELFARE
DISASTER
NATIONAL DEFENSE
ETC.......

MAGBAGO NAMAN KAYO.


Protect and Defend the Filipino Justice: At ALL COST

MSantiago: I would have voted you for President when you ran before because I saw you were a principled woman running the Bureau of Customs (if i remember the agency you head feistly, correctly). But where have your principles gone these days?
You, like Angara, all distinctly from University of the Philippines, I am ashamed of you 2, for defending a suspected, and many believe so, the Arroyo camp who are considered by many as tyrants, plunderers of Filipino wealth and sabotagers of the election and of Filipino future- using your senatorial clouts and perceived 'katusuhan', you are not using real intelligence for the benefit of the Filipino people.
You (senate and congress) were all sitting down, waiting which force will be stronger while my country was in the brink of chaos because the Arroyos demanded her midnight apppointed (in)justices to let her and her cohorts go out of the country!
Please do not give us pure technicalities as excuses for the Arroyos not face the crimes the people of the Philippines are clamoring that they be convicted. Please use your UP-trained brains and lawyering for the good of the people long been suffering because of corrupt officials!
Please do your job for the Filipino, all the Filipinos and not for the few who are plundering this country to poverty and chaos. Ang mga katulad ninyo ang nagbibigay kahihiyan sa ating bayan at nagiging dahilan upang tayo ay maging kaawa awa- subalit ang trabaho ninyo ay humanap ng paraan upang maging kagalang galang ang ating bayan at umunlad ang mamamayan. Napakalaki naman po ang sahod ng mamamayan sa inyo, kulang pa ito upang kampihan ninyo ang mga kinikilalang mandarambong at magnanakaw na kampon ni Arroyo?
Instead of giving the alibis, excuses and technicalities to get away, help us, the Filipino people to find ways on how to get justice through the laws that you are making. I am sure, there is a way to make JUSTICE HAPPEN in my country, using your combined intelligence in the lower house and Senate, we can have JUSTICE IN THE PHILIPPINES. Please stop giving us technicalities because the Filipino people are talking about life, future, dignity, integrity. I am sure the Philippine constitution enshrines these virtues as well and every tunay na Filipino would like to see the Truth to come out and not be delayed by technicalities tuso lawyers are famous for..
Huwag po nating idaan sa katusuhan ang kapakanan at kinabukasan ng bayan na lalo pang naghihirap. Stop Na! Help us stop the corruption in this country! Stop the pagtatakipan!
That is why, Filipino people like me are clamoring for IMPEACHMENT of the midnight appointed justices of Arroyo! While technically, the Supreme Court is held in highest esteem, the conduct of the Justices appointed by Arroyo are disgraceful, dishonorable and created dis unity in my country. The coronarroyo court deliberately BULLIED the Executive branch into doing the “law” they created illegally because they did not even provided the venue for reasons why the Arroyos must stay in the country to be stated and clarified.
Common sense tells us that the Arroyos must stay. Common people, who did not study law nor studied in UP can tell that to the (in)justices faces. But they abused their power by passing the TRO without consultation from concerned branch of government while as clear as broad daylight everybody knows it is of utmost importance. The people of the Philippines, though poor, are not dumb. Ang ginawa ng Supreme Court ay paglapastangan sa Constitusyon ng Pilipinas! Paglapastangan sa karapatan ng mamamayan na madinig at maproteksyonan ang aming interes, and for that Senate and Congress, they must be made to answer. The SC has done a grave crime and injustice to the people of the Philippines, a grave abuse of power. They must be IMPEACHED IMMEDIATELY!
As a Filipino, I am not taking what the (in)justices did sitting down. They have to be punished before the people of the Philippine’s court. Please do not make excuses for them or for the Arroyos. National security is national interest. The insistence of the Arroyo camp manipulating the coronarroyo court to make them travel abroad almost caused chaos in the Philippine Republic, what else do you want, MSantiago? Do you think the decision of the Supreme court can prevent the Filipino people from taking further action against the Arroyo cohorts? As former legitimately elected president Estrada pointed out, Arroyo must stay in the country and face the charges filed against her.
I do sincerely hope, the Senate and the Congress, at this point of Philippine history, will create a monumental change and be remembered forever in our books as honorable elected officials who stood ground for the Filipino people. Kahit isang beses lang, ipakita naman po ninyo na pinaglalaban ninyo kaming mga nagluklok sa inyong mga pwesto, kaming mga kumakayod at nagbubuwis ng pawis at dugo dito at sa ibang bayan upang kayo ay mabigyan ng matataas na sahod at malalaking pork barrel.
Huwag naman ninyo hayaan na bastusin ang Kataas-taasang Hukuman ng mga Mahina-stradong ito na maliwanag pa sa araw na mga tuta ni Arroyo! Kalapastanganan po sa sambayanang Filipino ang kanilang ginawa! Huwag na po natin bigyan ng teknikal arguments, malinaw sa lahat, manipulation at pambabastos ang kanilang ginawa!
The Filipino like me can also see through Lagman who initiated the idea of impeaching Pres. Aquino and whoever flaunted the idea of constitutional crisis. The Arroyo camp is the one feigning constitutional crises, creating chaos in my country! These are cases of treason, tyranny, inciting chaos, in my country – AND they have a clear reason, they want to escape prosecution. They are not going to get away with these crimes! They are the ones who must be IMPEACHED! They must be punished to the full extent of the law!
So please, kung meron pa kayong malasakit sa aking bayan, tama na ang pagpapahirap sa mga mamamayang Filipino, LET JUSTICE BE SERVED AT ALL COST.

Tagumpay Tayo

or otherwise as prescribed by law...

circular number 41 brought in during the administration of GMA was the basis of the travel ban imposed upon her...the bill of rights is clear that the no individual shall be deprived of his right to travel unless for the interets of national security, public safety, public health or otherwise as prescribed by law...even being accused and made bail, a person can still travel outside the country if he is not banned as prescribed by law, that he is a Flight Risk and will seek haven in a country where the Government of the Phl would not have jurisdiction. Circular 41 remedy this issue that even an individual still under investigation and considered a Flight Risk can preemptive to Fly and evade prosecution...and it is not ruled unconstitutional yet by the SC or any competent court of the land...until then, opinion such as Miriam's or anyone else would not matter much...


agree

I agree with tamy commentator. gma's leaving the country will pose threat to public health. people who have been hoping and waiting a long time for justice to be served will be most affected. if gma is allowed to leave, they will become depressed, lost appetite and maybe lost weight as well, just like gma. those who suffered depression will tell you the sickness is debilitating, caused them to have low morale and their work and family life are affected too.

but unlike gma, most have no money to buy expensive medicines from overseas and they cannot afford specialist treatment from st lukes. but their local doctors might be able to provide them medical abstracts that said they have depression and must be treated soonest.

and so our government will be forced to spend more on public health as more and more people will seek treatment for depression.

I'm afraid of consequences of what samsara commentator implied. I hope we will not get to that point. for if we do, god have mercy on me, I might join the movement.


agree

I agree with tamy commentator. gma's leaving the country will pose threat to public health. people who have been hoping and waiting a long time for justice to be served will be most affected. if gma is allowed to leave, they will become depressed, lost appetite and maybe lost weight as well, just like gma. those who suffered depression will tell you the sickness is debilitating, caused them to have low morale and their work and family life are affected too.

but unlike gma, most have no money to buy expensive medicines from overseas and they cannot afford specialist treatment from st lukes. but their local doctors might be able to provide them medical abstracts that said they have depression and must be treated soonest.

and so our government will be forced to spend more on public health as more and more people will seek treatment for depression.

I'm afraid of consequences of what samsara commentator implied. I hope we will not get to that point. for if we do, god have mercy one me, I might join the movement.


BAKIT?

BAKIT PA NATIN AANTAYIN NA MAGKAGULO SA PINAS
THE POSSIBILITY IS HIGH
MGA PILIPINO AY SAWANG SAWA NA SA MGA PANGUNGURAKOT NG MGA OPISYALES NG GOBIERNO
THE PRESENT GOVERNMENT HAS INSIGHT OF THE POSSIBLE WORST SCENARIO TO HAPPEN, SO IT IS PREVENTING IT.
MANY GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS UNDERMINE THE PILIPINO PEOPLE
MANY OF YOU ARE RUNNING FOR GOVERNMENT POST TO ENRICH YOURSELVES NOT TO WORK FOR OUR WELFARE.
MAHIYA NAMAN KAYO, AT MATAKOT SA DIYOS, ANG MGA PERA NAKUKURAKOT NINYO AY DI NINYO MADADALA SA HUKAY.
YOU WILL BE JUDGED BY YOUR DEEDS NOT BY YOUR POSITION OR MATERIAL POSITION WHEN YOU DIE.


tanga

be careful of the people called tanga. they do all the hard slug. they're the backbone that keeps our country going. push them too far and they might become lawless mob. mob can grew in number and be united. intellectuals might join their cause. and they'll easily become threat to our national security. and more than our public health will suffer.

the constitution did not help ex-president marcos. he got kicked out of our country. libya's constitution did not help gaddafi. egypt's constitution did not help mubarak. syria's contitution is crumbling. be careful with the tanga. they might give a different interpretation of the law and the constitution.


Ang layo ng analogy mo.

Ang premise mo puro setting leader ang mga napatalsik in extra constitutional way samantala sa usaping ito wala sa poder si Gloria. Si Abnoy ang naka upo ngayon at kung sya ang mapatalsik, masama ba yun?


Kawawa naman talaga ang ilan

Kawawa naman talaga ang ilan sa ating mga kababayan, nagmukhang tanga. Napaka linaw ng ating constitution na di sang ayon nito ang binigay na dahilan ng Abnoy camp na national interest. No less Senators Drilon, Escudero, Enrile, Santiago, Angara ang nagsabi na taliwas ang WLO sa constitution.



Links